Tax warranties
Statements about the company's tax history and compliance. We make sure they're accurate, and that anything that isn't is properly disclosed.
Tax warranties and indemnities
The sale agreement decides who pays for tax problems that surface after completion, mainly through the tax warranties and the tax covenant in the share purchase agreement. For sellers, poorly negotiated tax protections can mean years of exposure and money held back. For buyers, weak protections can mean inheriting someone else's tax bill. We make sure the tax terms are fair, clear and reflect what's actually known about the business.
Statements about the company's tax history and compliance. We make sure they're accurate, and that anything that isn't is properly disclosed.
The seller's promise to pay for tax relating to the period before completion. We negotiate its scope and the exclusions that should apply.
How much of the price, if any, is held back to cover tax risks, and whether warranty and indemnity insurance could offer a cleaner alternative.
Sellers: we limit your exposure after completion, make sure disclosures protect you, and push back on protections that are wider than the risks justify.
Buyers: we make sure the protections match the risks found in tax due diligence, and that specific known issues are covered by specific indemnities.
FAQs
A tax warranty is a statement of fact about the company's tax affairs. If it's untrue, the buyer usually has to prove its loss to make a claim. A tax indemnity, often in a separate tax covenant or tax deed, is a promise to pay for specific tax liabilities on a pound-for-pound basis, without the buyer needing to prove loss.
It's negotiated, but tax claims commonly run for 4 to 7 years after completion, reflecting how long HMRC can typically go back to raise an assessment. Sellers should aim for clear time limits, caps and minimum claim thresholds.
It's insurance, usually bought by the buyer, that covers losses from breaches of warranties and certain indemnities. It's common in private equity deals and can allow sellers a cleaner exit, with less of the sale price held back or at risk.
A disclosure letter lists exceptions to the warranties, such as an open HMRC enquiry or a known tax error. Matters that are fairly disclosed usually can't then form the basis of a warranty claim. Disclosure doesn't normally limit claims under a tax covenant, though, so known tax issues need to be dealt with in the covenant itself.
Yes. Sale agreements usually include an overall cap on the seller's liability, and tax claims are often subject to their own cap, which can be higher than for other warranties. Minimum claim thresholds and time limits also apply. The levels are negotiated, so it helps to agree the principles at heads of terms stage.
Common exclusions include tax already provided for in the completion accounts, tax arising in the ordinary course of business after the last accounts date, and tax caused by the buyer's actions after completion. Changes in law after completion are often excluded too. These exclusions are what stop the covenant becoming a blank cheque for the buyer.
After completion the buyer controls the company, so it will normally deal with HMRC. The sale agreement usually includes conduct of claims provisions, giving the seller the right to be kept informed and sometimes to lead the defence of pre-completion issues. Sellers should make sure these rights are clear, because they can affect the outcome of a claim.
Yes. In a share sale the buyer takes on the company with its full tax history, so tax warranties and a tax covenant are standard. In an asset sale most of the company's tax liabilities stay with the seller, so the tax protections are usually narrower, often focused on areas like VAT and employees who transfer. The scope should match the deal structure.
Usually not. W&I insurance generally excludes matters the buyer already knows about, including issues found in due diligence or disclosed by the seller. Known tax risks are normally dealt with through a specific indemnity from the seller, a retention, an adjustment to the price, or sometimes a separate tax insurance policy.
A buyer will usually want tax warranties, a tax covenant covering tax relating to the period before completion, and specific indemnities for any risks found in due diligence. Where the seller's ability to pay is a concern, a retention or escrow may also be appropriate. The protections should be proportionate to the risks actually identified.
It depends on the drafting. Buyers often ask for sellers to be jointly and severally liable, which means each seller could be pursued for the whole claim. Sellers usually push for liability in proportion to their share of the sale proceeds. This is particularly important for minority shareholders and those who aren't involved in running the business.
It's a promise by the sellers to pay the buyer, pound for pound, for tax the company has to pay that relates to the period before completion and wasn't provided for in the accounts. It usually sits in a schedule to the share purchase agreement or in a separate tax deed. Unlike a warranty claim, the buyer doesn't have to prove the company's value fell. Sellers protect themselves by negotiating exclusions, time limits, a cap and conduct of claims rules, so they aren't paying for tax caused by the buyer's own actions after completion.
Related advice
Specialist tax advice for business owners selling a company worth £1m to £50m. Reliefs, pre-sale structuring, deal terms and HMRC clearances.
Read moreTax due diligence for private equity, family offices, trade buyers and individual acquirers. Red-flag or full reports, SPA tax review and W&I-ready findings.
Read moreTax advice for private equity, family offices, trade buyers and individuals buying a business: due diligence, structuring and SPA protections.
Read moreBring us in before the tax terms are agreed. Book a call.
Or write to taxadvisory@aswatax.co.uk
